3CE Lip Pigments / OCC Lip Tar Dupes | Review

3CE 1When these finally arrived at work for me after a 2-3 week delivery waiting time  from China, it was typically a day that Lauren was off sick. This meant that my yelps of “Look! Look what’s came! Look what they do!” were largely ignored by all the boys in the  office, who looked at me blankly for about 2 seconds before going back to talking about, I don’t know, servers or something.

I was SUPER excited about them though because as I say I’d been waiting flippin’ weeks for them and couldn’t wait to give them a whirl.

Most people are familiar with Obsessive Compulsive Cosmetics’ cult ‘Lip Tars’. These are highly pigmented products that are meant to have the smoothness of a gloss but the longevity of a lipstick – so a bit similar to Stila’s liquid lipsticks or Rimmel’s Apocalips, but the pigment factor means that the tiny tubes are meant to last you FOREVER. The range is also completely mixable and contains black, white, yellow and blue so that you can get all jazzy and creative with your lip colours. I’ve heard quite a few people rave about the OCC Lip tars, but at £11 each they’ve never sneaked their way to the top of my ‘to buy’ list.

3CE 2

3CE 11But when I saw these 3CE lip pigments on someone’s Instagram (I wish I could remember whose, let me know if you’re reading this and it was yours!) my interest was piqued. Now, there have been a few high street attempt at OCC dupes – Sleek’s Pout Paints being one – but none as far as I know that are as cheap as these. Brace yourselves, women and children, for these are just £1.90 each. China, you never fail to amaze me.

I immediately decided to snap one up to see if they were any good. And then accidentally ended up snapping up 4. But at those prices, how could I say no? So with free delivery I had all four of the above products sent to me for just £7.60.

There are 7 shades to choose from, but I decided on the somewhat randomly named White, Plum, A1 (..?!) and Pink. When they arrived, these were thankfully labelled on the boxes in a much more understandable system of 01, 02, 03 and 04. 01 is the white mixing colour, 02 is a bright purple-pink, 03 a deep orange and 04 is my go-to colour of choice, a pale peachy-pink. Each pigment comes in a box with its own little lip brush.


3CE 3As you can see, the word pigment is CORRECT and these are very bright shades. The consistency is thick and not runny, but then not so thick it’s difficult to blend – it’s basically like those stupid expensive paints in the tubes you had to buy if you did GCSE Art (which are a proper waste of money when you only come out with a C, puh).

I found application a leeeeeeeetle bit tricky just because I’m not used to using a lip brush – also I suspect that the ones provided are too small to do the job properly, unless you have tiny thin lips or are planning to put these on your grandad. With a bit of a combination of lip brush action and some good old fashioned finger dabbing though, I eventually applied a nice coat of each for your perusal:

3CE 4

3ce 5

3CE 6

Mixed Swatches

The really exciting part of the pigments for me comes when you get to the mixing. Although they can all be mixed with each other, I decided to keep it simple and so below is each colour mixed in equal parts with the white 01 shade.

3ce 7Stating the obvious here but this created a lighter, more pastel version of each shade. I personally liked these colours more than the non-mixed versions, just because I’m not really a ‘bright lipstick in the day’ sort of person so these were much more in my comfort zone. I also don’t think stark orange looks very nice against my skin tone, whereas the more peachy colour that’s created when 01 is mixed in is much more wearable. I think the addition of the white also made each pigment look a bit glossier, though it’s also possible that I’d just got better at application by this point and wasn’t being such a cack-handed idiot.

3CE 8

3CE 9

3CE 10Ever a creature of habit, the final pale pink colour of 01+04 is of course my favourite, though I honestly do like the whole shade range.

I suppose the negative of these products is the fussiness of application in regards to the brush etc. It’s not a big problem with the individual shades as I have since found that finger application is okay; but when it comes to mixing up colours with the white then this definitely becomes a little less practical. You could find the perfect shade for a night out, but re-application is going to become a bit of a nightmare unless you want to crack out your artist’s palette and start mixing shades in the toilets of a nightclub.

The counter-argument to this though (ooft, mention of my GCSEs seems to have brought out the essayist in me) is that the high pigmentation means that the colour lasts. I would definitely back this claim up; I wore 04 to work yesterday and even after a good few hours there was still a strong stain of colour on my lips. Although my lips definitely started to feel dry and I had to slap a bit of lip balm on, I’m also happy to report that it didn’t end up caking or clinging to dry parts of my lips too much, which is always a worry of mine.

Overall I am vair, vair impressed with these cheap little beauties. The shade range of the OCC Lip tars is far more extensive and after watching a few Youtube videos with them in, they do look like they apply a bit slicker than these 3CE dupes. For the money though, you can’t complain. You just can’t, or I’ll have to proclaim you to be some sort of pedantic fool.

As I said, these lip pigments were just £1.90 and I bought them from this seller –  I can’t see them listed there anymore, but plenty of others also do them. As in most cases, you can find UK sellers who will get them to you much quicker but they’ll cost you a good few quid more.

Have any of you tried these, or any other 3CE products? Or are you loyal to OCC? Let me know what you think in the comments below, and leave your blog links too!

12 Responses

  1. vickie September 21, 2013 / 9:33 am

    Yey it’s up! I’ve been so intrigues by these since you posted them on your Instagram (its an endless circle). I now just have to give these a whirl, love a good make your own lip colour I’m guessing it’s the kid in me that enjoyed sploshing paint everywhere! 🙂

    P.s. that Grandad line just made me howl! Fantastic review my love!

    • Claire September 21, 2013 / 3:18 pm

      Indeed, I’m going to play around mixing them aaaaaall up and see what atrocities masterpiece colours I can come up with! Haha thanks boo 🙂 xx

  2. Kat September 21, 2013 / 12:27 pm

    I was looking at the OCC Lip Tars literally yesterday evening and thinking they were a tad pricey then this post pops up, good timing! These look really good and what a bargainous price. Love the combos you created 🙂 xx

    Curls & Swirls Beauty Blog

    • Claire September 21, 2013 / 3:19 pm

      Ah brilliant- I’m sure the Lip Tars are amazing but they’re so pricey, definitely give these a whirl first and see if they suit you 🙂 xx

  3. Annie September 22, 2013 / 10:13 am

    They sell wee empty pots in Superdrug for pennies for putting creams in when you go on holiday etc – maybe buy a few of those, pre-mix and take them out?

    • Annie September 22, 2013 / 10:25 am

      Oh, and try Carmex Moisture Plus if you haven’t already – lip balms with colour in (and they do a pink one!)

    • Claire September 22, 2013 / 10:56 am

      One of my friends suggested this last night and it seems like it could be the answer to my prayers! Thanks 🙂 xx

    • Claire October 7, 2013 / 7:43 pm

      As far as I know they’re authentic as all the others I found on the net are a similar price – maybe that other website is just quite overpriced? Obviously I wasn’t familiar with the brand before trying these so can’t say for sure what the prices are usually like, but these are really good quality so I don’t think they’re at all dodgy – or if they are, then they’re incredibly good dupes! 🙂 xx

  4. jamjar August 5, 2014 / 3:46 pm

    Hey, so there are a few ways to tell if it is a 3CE dupe: if the colors on the box did not match the colors on the tube, if the box says 12g instead of the correct 11g, and if there is a not smooth black area that is flat underneath the ribbed area at the top (the crimped closure will have a smooth but also closed area under it) the fakes have only the crimp and then open area for the lip pigment. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_t9wMi-Kysw this is a video showing the differences. (sorry none of it is in english but she shows it all clearly)

    Honestly, I am hoping that you got a dupe and not the real deal because I want to order a dupe but I don’t want it to be poor quality, it sounds like what you got is awesome. Here is the link to a seller who does the whole set for pretty cheap http://www.aliexpress.com/item/New-Coming-3CE-Authentic-Korean-Shine-Lip-Pigment-Makeup-Liquid-Lipstick-Lip-Gloss-T1029-Free-Shipping/1849530566.html the pictures are straight from the website so clearly I can’t tell from the online descriptions if it’s real or a dupe.

    • Claire August 5, 2014 / 5:25 pm

      Thanks for all of the info, this is really interesting as I’d never heard of 3CE before so had no idea if they were expensive/worth duping. I’m really happy with these products though, so if you are after a good version then I’d recommend them… but out of curiosity I’ll definitely check those details later to see if they’re fakeys! 🙂 xx

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.